APPROVAL OF MINUTES
April 10, 2006, Board of Commissioners
Regular Meeting
On motion by Commissioner Miller, seconded by Commissioner
Wolfe, and carried unanimously, the Port of Vancouver USA
Board of Commissioners approved the minutes of the April
10, 2006, regular meeting as distributed.
OPEN FORUM
Commission President Baker
invited comments from the audience regarding any matter
not listed on the agenda.
Kent Williams, representing the Fort Vancouver Seafarers
Center, said that he was proud to attend this meeting and
mentioned that his organization was working hard to meet
the needs of seafarers at the Port of Vancouver.
ACTION ITEMS
Authorization to Solicit for Flexible Services
Facilities Director Curtis Shuck presented the staff report,
as contained in the agenda packet, and discussed the proposal
with the Commissioners. He explained that the request was
for authorization to solicit a Request for Qualifications
from consultants for professional engineering and architectural
services for Fiscal Year 2006 through Fiscal Year 2008.
He added that selected consultants would be placed on the
flexible services list and used on an "as-needed,"
rotational basis within each professional category in order
to equalize usage. He acknowledged that Resolution 6-04,
"Administrative Authority of Executive Director and
His Designees," would govern the monetary limit of
contracts that can be executed under the flexible services
list. He pointed out that currently, the executive director
can execute contracts for architecture and engineering services
that are below $100,000, and all consultant contracts greater
than $100,000 need Commission approval and are normally
publicly advertised. He said that aggregate limits for consultant
firms that provide services from the Architecture and Engineering
Flexible Services list can not exceed $500,000 for the period
of performance (2006-2008).
Facilities Director Shuck explained that the Architecture/Engineering
Flexible Services List is a valuable and beneficial tool
for Port staff because it allows the Port to expeditiously
execute contracts for professional services by reducing
the need for a separate solicitation for each required service.
He pointed out that, additionally, use of the pre-qualified
list reduces consultant time and effort in preparing separate
qualification packets to meet Port needs.
Contracts Officer Becky Eisiminger discussed the Port's
contracts program with the Commissioners. In response to
concerns raised by Commissioner Miller about firms complaining
that they are not informed of Port solicitations, she explained
that vendors can access information regarding solicitations
from the Port's webpage using the E-Bid system.
Ms. Eisiminger asked that Commissioners direct inquiries
and complaints regarding Port contracts to her so that she
can show vendors how to utilize the Port's E-Bid system.
After further discussion, Executive Director Paulson acknowledged
that it was not a perfect system but that staff endeavors
to distribute as much information about solicitations as
possible and the process is a good one that does work successfully.
On motion by Commissioner Baker, seconded by Commissioner
Wolfe, and carried unanimously, the Port of Vancouver USA
Board of Commissioners authorized the executive director
to conduct a solicitation for "Architecture/Engineering
Flexible Services."
UNFINISHED BUSINESS
Approval of Resolution
5-2006
The Board of Commissioners acknowledged receipt
of a revised version of Resolution 5-2006, adopted at the
April 10, 2006, regular meeting, which included two additional
paragraphs requested by the Commission, as follows:
WHEREAS, Boise is currently planning to sell most of the
remainder of its surrounding real property for multi-use
purposes, including commercial and residential uses, consistent
with the City of Vancouver's publicized vision; and
WHEREAS, the proposed development and change in use will
impact the viability of the Port of Vancouver maintaining
the adjacent 2.9 acre tracts as industrial land; and
..
The Commissioners agreed that the two additional paragraphs
sufficiently captured their directions to staff during the
April 10 discussion of the proposal and agreed to sign the
revised resolution as contained in the agenda packet.
NEW BUSINESS
Consideration of Increasing Salary for Port
of Vancouver USA Board of Commissioners
Commissioner Miller explained that the Port
Commission is the only governmental body in the state of
Washington that is authorized by the Revised Code of Washington
to set its own salary. He also mentioned that when the commissioners'
salary is revised, the change does not happen until the
next term of office begins. The Commissioners discussed
the local boards salary survey presented by staff and said
that the only comparable Clark County board was the Clark
Public Utilities.
At the request of the Commissioners, staff agreed to provide
comparable salary data from other Washington ports, including
whether or not other ports have taken action to increase
their salaries, to the Commissioners for their further consideration
of this matter at the May 9, 2006, regular meeting. It was
pointed out that commission per diem allowances, totaling
$70 per day, are established by the state legislature and
cannot be revised by the local board of commissioners.
EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR
AND STAFF REPORTS
Facilities Director Curtis Shuck presented an Industrial
Marketing Team quarterly report to the Commissioners. He
advised that he, Port Property Administrator Linda Carlson,
and Andy Kanges, from CB Richard Ellis, held a quarterly
Industrial Marketing Team meeting with representatives of
the City of Vancouver, the Columbia River Economic Development
Council, Leadership Clark County and the Greater Vancouver
Chamber of Commerce. He added that they reviewed the Port's
Industrial Marketing Plan and discussed current Port projects,
as well as potential projects of mutual concern.
Deputy Executive Director Todd Coleman reported on a Neighborhood
Association Council of Clark County meeting that he and
Commissioner Wolfe attended on April 10. He reported that
approximately 20 Clark County neighborhood association representatives
attended the meeting and were generally supportive of the
Port's development plans, including the need for rail access
and the creation of additional jobs in Clark County.
Executive Director Paulson reported on a "Citizens
Forum on Rail" which the Port conducted on April 11.
He reported that the forum was an opportunity for Port staff
to relay short-term rail plans to the community. Mr. Paulson
commended Community Relations Manager Katy Brooks for her
efforts to keep the Port and the community actively engaged
in discussions regarding operations and future plans.
Mr. Paulson relayed the following information:
- A Columbia Gateway key agency meeting was held April
12.
- The Washington Transportation Commission conducted a
"Rail Study Listening Session" on April 13 at
the Port.
- A Project Partners Team meeting was held April 13. Deputy
Executive Director Coleman explained that the PPT is a
group of community stakeholders who are engaged in ongoing
communications, regarding current and future Port projects,
with Port staff. He added that the stakeholders relay
that information to other community leaders on behalf
of the Port.
- He attended an April 18 Propeller Club meeting where
PNWA Executive Director Glenn Vanselow gave a presentation
on this year's "Mission to Washington."
" He, along with City Transportation Manager Thayer
Rorabaugh, attended a Freight Mobility Strategic Investment
Board (FMSIB) meeting in Seattle on April 19. Executive
Director Paulson said that grant presentations on the
26th Avenue and South Rail Projects were discussed at
the meeting.
- The annual auditors exit interview, including Commissioner
Baker, Executive Director Paulson and Finance Director
Smith with representatives of the State Auditors Office,
was held April 24 and the results were positive. Executive
Director Paulson said that receipt of a final, written
report was anticipated within the next few weeks, and
he would share that information with the Commission as
soon as it is available.
Commissioner Baker mentioned that the auditors were highly
complementary of the efforts of the Marketing and Operations
Department during the exit interview. Executive Director
Paulson agreed with Commissioner Baker and said that the
auditors were also very complimentary of the Finance and
Purchasing/Contracts functions of the Port.
Executive Director Paulson reminded the Commissioners of
the 7:30 a.m., April 28, Port of Vancouver USA Legislative
Event at the Port.
Mr. Paulson also reminded the Commissioners of a Port presentation
to the University Women's Group at 1 p.m. on April 24; a
4 p.m., April 25, Columbia River Crossing Task Force meeting;
a Port presentation to the Executive Club at 7 a.m. on April
27; a joint City/Port Workshop regarding the Columbia River
waterfront development plans at City Hall from 4 to 6 p.m.
on May 1; and, a Port visit by Representative Deb Wallace
on May 3rd.
Executive Director Paulson commended Facilities Director
Curtis Shuck, Facilities Superintendent Todd Krout and Procurement
Project Manager Rick Cline for their efforts in developing
the Port's alternative fuels program.
Sr. Marketing and Operations Manager Alastair Smith gave
a report on his recent marketing trip to Canada where he
and Terminal Manager Ken Mishler visited seven Port of Vancouver
customers. He relayed that all customers were supportive
of the Port and generally pleased with the service they
have received. Director Smith added that the customers were
happy to receive news that the Port was in the process of
purchasing a heavy lift crane. He said that they volunteered
to assist in the Port's marketing efforts by relaying news
relative to the new crane to their international brokers,
which could generate more project-type cargo at the Port.
Director Smith reported that two concerns were raised during
the meetings: (1) an insufficient number of qualified longshoremen
available on ships during peak workloads, which creates
delays, and (2) that PMA does not provide adequate training
funds for longshoremen to perform crane work or any type
of work on break bulk cargoes. He added that both issues
are being addressed by the Port of Vancouver, PMA and Local
4 and that the Port of Vancouver USA may be selected as
a training site by PMA.
Executive Director Paulson reported that several associates
of AON, the Port's insurance brokers, have left that organization.
Finance Director Smith added that Debbie Bovee and a number
of other employees have left AON to work at another brokerage
firm. Ms. Smith and Mr. Paulson stated that a lack of continuity
with broker services, especially losing the history with
Debbie Bovee and the other brokers who have Port-related
backgrounds, could be detrimental to the Port. She added
that additional information regarding that impact on the
Port of Vancouver's contract renewal discussions with AON
would be forthcoming once she had an opportunity to discuss
the matter with the seven other Washington ports finance
representatives included in the state-wide insurance pool.
Executive Director Paulson mentioned a proposal related
to a twenty percent local funding match, or $372,000, from
the Regional Transportation Council (RTC) for a $1.488 million
High Capacity Transit Corridor Study. He added that Clark
County identified $150,000 and was seeking support for the
balance. Mr. Paulson said that he did not have any further
information regarding the issue and was bringing it to the
attention of the Commission in case they were contacted
individually about the funding request.
Commissioner Miller, a member of the RTC Board, relayed
that the RTC 2006 Work Program included a high capacity
transit study to determine high capacity transit within
Clark County. He said that as a part of the Columbia River
I-5 Bridge Task Force, there was also a high capacity transit-on-the-bridge
study being conducted, but the two studies are completely
independent and not being communicated to each other. He
said that after the I-5 Columbia River Crossing Study determines
what high capacity transit should be put on the new bridge,
tunnel or other alternative developed, it will end just
north of the Columbia River and, separately, the High Capacity
Study that is being done will determine what to do within
Clark County. Commissioner Miller said that as a result,
a third study would be needed to determine how to connect
the two studies together, and he felt the situation was
asinine. He added that C-TRAN understands that light rail,
which is the probable high capacity transit system that
will be developed across the bridge, is not what is needed
in Clark County since the urban density of Portland does
not exist in Clark County. Commissioner Miller went on to
say that at a recent RTC meeting Mayor Pollard suggested
that the City of Vancouver and C-TRAN provide the balance
of money needed for the local grant and C-TRAN declined
the mayor's suggestion. Commissioner Miller stated that
he was not in favor of the Port of Vancouver contributing
any funds to the project unless C-TRAN agrees to provide
an acceptable level of contribution to the project.
NEW BUSINESS (Continued)
Dave Hunt, representing the Association of Pacific
Ports (APP), requested that the Port of Vancouver USA, consider
renewing its membership in the APP. He explained that last
Fall the Columbia River Channel Coalition staff assumed
management of the Association of Pacific Ports and the organization
has taken a new direction, specifically focusing on education
and networking in areas of common interest among ports from
a commissioner's perspective.
The Commissioners and Executive Director Paulson discussed
the request with Mr. Hunt.
Commissioner Miller mentioned that the Port of Vancouver
currently holds membership in the Washington Public Ports
Association, the Pacific Northwest Waterways Association,
and the American Association of Port Authorities. He added
that the Port does not have any representation in the Pacific
region where the bulk of its business is generated.
Commissioner Miller acknowledged that the Port previously
belonged to the Association of Pacific Ports but declined
membership because a fair return on investment was not being
received. He voiced optimism that under Mr. Hunt's direction,
the organization would improve and provide a viable return
on investment to its membership.
Executive Director Paulson praised Mr. Hunt's expertise
and recommended favorable consideration of the request.
Commissioner Baker stated that as a former member of Port
staff, she learned a lot through the Port's association
with the Association of Pacific Ports and she felt that
the networking potential for the commissioners was beneficial.
Commissioner Baker added that the past burden of hosting
the annual meetings became overwhelming to many ports in
the association and she was glad to learn that under Mr.
Hunt's direction, the individual ports would not be burdened
with that hosting task.
After further discussion, it was agreed that the request
would be placed on the May 9 agenda for further consideration.
Commissioner Baker thanked Mr. Hunt for attending the meeting,
as well as his interest in the Port of Vancouver.
COMMISSIONER REPORTS
Commissioner Wolfe encouraged Commissioners Baker and
Miller to attend some of the Port outreach meetings that
are being conducted by staff. Commissioner Wolfe said that
he had gained valuable port-related knowledge and experience
by attending several of those community meetings and it
was a positive experience for him.
Commissioner Wolfe reported on a CREDC Executive Committee
meeting that he attended, as well as a recent trip to Oakland,
California, where he was unable to participate in a Port
of Oakland tour that had been arranged by Vancouver Port
Communications Manager Maureen Chan-Hefflin. He thanked
Ms. Chan-Hefflin for her efforts to coordinate the tour
and said that since his son resides in Oakland, he plans
to return there and participate in the port tour at a later
date.
Commissioner Miller stated that he appreciated Commissioner
Wolfe's encouragement that he and Commissioner Baker also
attend port-related community meetings, but added that staff
would need to contact him with details about those meetings
and provide as much advance notice as possible.
Commissioner Miller reported that he attended a Columbia
River Crossing Project Sponsors meeting on April 13 where
approval of the reduction of nine alternatives was agreed
upon. He said that on April 13 he also attended a farewell
reception honoring Lynne Griffith at C-TRAN and a Columbia
River Crossing Open House at Jantzen Beach.
Commissioner Miller stated that he spent time in the Emergency
Room at Southwest Washington Medical Center as a guest,
at the invitation of Executive Director Joe Kortum, where
he was allowed to "shadow" a registered nurse
for two hours. He said the experience was a positive one
that showed him that the emergency room is very organized,
and he encouraged the other Commissioners to seize an opportunity
to do the same.
Commissioner Miller stated that he attended a meeting of
the RTC Corridor Vision Group where direction of the group
was established and agreed upon for presentation to the
RTC Board at its regular May meeting for approval.
Commissioner Miller reported that on April 19 he conducted
a tour of the Port of Vancouver for Jack Burkman, a Democratic
candidate for a state representative position.
Commissioner Miller reported that he attended the initial
meeting of the Portland Metropolitan Transit Plan update
on April 20. He added that a series of meetings regarding
the update would be held in the future.
Commissioner Baker reported that she gave a welcome speech
at the Clark County Discovery Trails System Dedication Ceremony
at Vancouver Landing on April 6. She also attended a Lewis
and Clark Bicentennial Luncheon immediately following the
dedication ceremony and a reception that evening.
Commissioner Baker reported that she spoke to the Fort
Vancouver Retirement Center's Men's Group, where she had
an opportunity to visit with Freeman Keller, a long-time
community activist who formerly lived in her neighborhood.
Commissioner Baker also reported that she attended the
Washington State Transportation Commission's "Rail
Study Listening Session" on April 13 at the Port; Lynne
Griffith's farewell reception at C-TRAN; the Confluence
Project dedication ceremony at Cape Disappointment, where
she had an opportunity to spend time with former Governor
Gary Locke and Maya Lin, on April 22; and the audit exit
interview on April 24.
Commissioner Baker added that she attended the Lincoln
Neighborhood Association and Northwest Neighborhood Association
meetings recently. She commended Community Relations Manager
Katy Brooks and Deputy Executive Director Todd Coleman for
their presentations at those meetings.
Commissioner Miller gave history on his past experiences
welcoming, in his home, new executives to the Vancouver
community and encouraged others to open their homes and
welcome Lynne Griffith's replacement at C-TRAN, as well
as other newcomers, to the Vancouver business community.
WORKSHOP
The Board of Commissioners and staff conducted a workshop
on (1) the Port's current capital projects program and (2)
a cash flow presentation from 11:30 a.m. until 12:50 p.m.
ADJOURNMENT
There being no further business
to come before the Port of Vancouver USA Board of Commissioners,
the April 25, 2006, regular meeting was recessed at 12:50
p.m. by Commission President Baker.