APPROVAL OF MINUTES
April 25, 2006, Regular Meeting
On motion by Commissioner Miller, seconded by Commissioner
Wolfe, and carried unanimously, the Port of Vancouver USA
Board of Commissioners approved the minutes of the April
25, 2006, regular meeting as distributed.
OPEN FORUM
Commission President Baker invited comments regarding
any items not listed on the agenda from the audience.
Kent Williams, representing the Fort Vancouver Seafarers
Center, invited all interested supporters and those interested
in learning more about the Center to attend its 6 p.m.,
May 20, annual meeting at the Seafarers Center.
ACTION ITEMS
Authorize Purchase and Sale Agreement between
the Port of Vancouver USA and Cadet Manufacturing Company
and Anderson Realty Investments, LLC
Facilities Director Curtis Shuck presented the staff report,
as contained in the agenda packet, and discussed the proposal
with the commissioners. He explained that the Port conducted
negotiations with Cadet Manufacturing Company and Anderson
Realty Investments, LLC to acquire approximately 11 acres
of real property located at 2500 West Fourth Plain Blvd.
He added that the property was being purchased "as
is," "where is" and "with all faults."
Mr. Shuck reminded the Commissioners that acquisition of
the property would allow the Port to maintain its record
of high level environmental clean-up, in cooperation with
the Department of Ecology, as well as provide a development
potential for other revenue producing opportunities offered
by the property.
Director Shuck said the proposed settlement agreement between
the Port and Cadet included a provision for a portion of
the property to be leased back to Cadet Manufacturing at
current market value which would allow its facility to continue
production and maintain the 100+ full time jobs that Cadet
Manufacturing Company currently provides to the community.
Director Shuck also said that a purchase and sale agreement
was prepared as an element of the proposed settlement agreement
with a final purchase price for the 4.93 acre Cadet Manufacturing
Company property and the 6.07 acre Anderson Realty Investments,
LLC property of $5,445,938.00. He added that Cascade Title
Company of Vancouver, Washington, would provide title insurance
and escrow for the transaction.
Commissioners Baker and Miller both said they were happy
that this phase in the Port's association with Cadet had
passed and added that it was time to work together as a
team and complete the TCE cleanup on the site as quickly
as possible. They thanked Hutch Johnson and Dick Anderson
for their cooperation and efforts over the years.
On motion by Commissioner Wolfe, seconded by Commissioner
Miller, and carried unanimously, the Port of Vancouver USA
Board of Commissioners approved the purchase and sale agreement
with Cadet Manufacturing Company and Anderson Realty Investments,
LLC for the real property located at 2500 Fourth Plain Blvd,
Vancouver, Washington, at the final purchase price of $5,445,938.00,
for execution by the Board of Commissioners and directed
the Executive Director to sign all other documents necessary
for closing the transaction.
Request for Approval
of Lease with Cadet Manufacturing
Facilities Director Curtis Shuck presented the staff report,
as contained in the agenda packet, and discussed the proposal
with the commissioners. He explained that the settlement
agreement between Cadet Manufacturing Company and the Port
of Vancouver USA, dated February 1, 2006, stipulated that
upon the closing of the Cadet property sale, the Port would
lease a portion of the property, including the Cadet buildings,
back to Cadet on mutually agreed upon terms. He said that
the terms of the lease were negotiated by the Port and Cadet
and provide that the property be leased to Cadet "as
is," "where is" and "with all faults."
He added that the lease included two parcels: (1) Parcel
1: approximately 64,388 square feet of manufacturing and
warehouse, including approximately 16,073 square feet of
office space on a total site area of approximately 173,804.4
square feet and (2) Parcel 2: approximately 2.76 acres of
access and storage space.
Director Shuck said that the initial term of the lease
was for 60 months (5 years) beginning June 1, 2006, and
terminating May 31, 2011, and Cadet was granted two (2)
five-year (5-yr) renewal options. He said that base rent
was $31,991.77 per month for the original lease term. He
added that termination of the lease could happen with at
least one year's written notice of intent to terminate and
if the Lessee requests early termination, there would be
additional "Early Termination Rent" due. He pointed
out that the total anticipated revenue from the initial
term of the lease would be $1,919,506.20.
On motion by Commissioner Miller, seconded by Commissioner
Wolfe, and carried unanimously, the Port of Vancouver USA
Board of Commissioners approved the Cadet Manufacturing
Company lease for 60 months in the POV-owned building located
at 2500 Fourth Plain Blvd, Vancouver, WA.
The Port Commissioners and Hutch Johnson and Dick Anderson,
representing Cadet, signed the purchase and sale agreement,
as well as the lease agreement.
Executive Director Paulson thanked Mr. Johnson and Mr.
Anderson for their past cooperation and assistance, especially
relative to environmental clean up issues, and said the
Port and Cadet had experienced legal differences, but had
never experienced differences of opinion relative to working
with the neighborhood. He added that Cadet had always been
a good neighbor to the Port and he was looking forward to
that same positive experience in the future. Both responded
by saying they shared Mr. Paulson's feelings.
Consideration of American Pacific Ports (APP) Membership
Executive Director Larry Paulson presented the staff report,
as contained in the agenda packet, and discussed the proposal
with the commissioners. He said that staff believed membership
in APP would provide Pacific Rim-related benefits to the
Port of Vancouver USA that are not currently provided by
current memberships in the American Association of Port
Authorities, Washington Public Ports Association and the
Pacific Northwest Waterways Association. He recommended
that consideration be given to a one-year, trial-based membership
which would give the Port Commissioners an opportunity to
determine whether or not continued membership would be warranted.
Mr. Paulson pointed out that membership in APP would require
attendance at out of town meetings and annual conferences
by Commissioners.
On motion by Commissioner Miller, seconded by Commissioner
Wolfe, and carried unanimously, the Port of Vancouver USA
Board of Commissioners authorized the Executive Director
to apply for Port of Vancouver USA membership in the Association
of Pacific Ports (APP) for the fiscal year August 1, 2006,
through July 31, 2007, in the amount of $3,000, with the
understanding that the Port of Vancouver USA would not be
represented at its 2006 annual conference in Saipan. It
was agreed that selection of a Port Commission representative
for APP would be made during the annual budget planning
process.
Authorize a Contract with Liebherr Cranes, Inc. for a
Mobile Harbor Crane
Sr. Marketing and Operations Manager Alastair Smith presented
the staff report, as contained in the agenda packet, and
discussed the proposal with the commissioners. He reminded
the Commissioners that the Port's strategic plan includes
a vision to be "a premier port that is globally recognized
and well capitalized with state of the art facilities, infrastructure
and service" and that Goal #1 in the strategic plan
is to "increase the volume of cargo at the Port of
Vancouver." Director Smith said that in order to attain
this vision and goal, the Port must prepare for future,
diversified cargo needs and he requested authorization to
award a contract to procure a mobile harbor crane which
would provide the following benefits to the Port: (1) increased
efficiency of terminal operations; (2) increased operational
lift capacity to support future cargo; and (3) the Port's
increased competitive edge by attracting additional, diversified
cargo. He reported that continued marketing efforts had
identified additional Pacific Northwest business opportunities
to support the acquisition of a mobile harbor crane.
Director Smith said that on March 13, 2006, the Port solicited
proposals for a mobile harbor crane and one addendum was
issued on March 22. He added that three proposals were received
on March 28 and the Port conducted oral discussions with
two of the firms on April 4th and received a "Best
and Final Offer" from each firm. He said that Liebherr
Cranes, Inc. was recommended for award of a heavy lift mobile
harbor crane for a not to exceed amount of $3,276,650 and
that the price included transport, installation and commissioning
necessary for a "turn-key" handover of the crane.
Mr. Smith pointed out that the Port would be responsible
for providing equipment to support the installation of the
crane, as well as for import fees and taxes, but the purchase
was exempt from Washington State Sales Tax. He went on to
say that four installment payments would be made based on
project milestones - contract signing; loading at embarkation
port; arrival at the Port of Vancouver USA; and the Certificate
of Completion signing. Director Smith relayed that according
to the terms of the agreement, the crane would be positioned,
commissioned, certified and ready to perform 130 days from
the date of signing, which would be October 10, 2006. He
expressed hope that the new crane would be used during the
final phase of the Wild Horse Wind Turbine Project for Vestas
at the Port.
Executive Director Paulson reminded the Commissioners that
he had been given authorization previously to purchase a
crane not to exceed $4.1 million and he was pleased that
the final purchase price would not exceed $3,276,650. He
commended Director Smith and other involved Port staff,
as well as ILWU Local 4 representatives Steve Kadow, Eric
VonHusen and Todd Walker, for the successful negotiations
resulting in this proposal.
Commissioner Wolfe asked if any additional equipment for
operating the crane, and not included in the final purchase
price, would need to be acquired by the Port. Director Smith
explained that the Port had agreed to supply the equipment
necessary for erection of the crane which meant rental of
a Star Shipping crane on the port for the erection. He added
that once the crane becomes operational, the Port would
likely need to supply some lifting frames based upon types
of cargo being unloaded. He said that the stevedores had
agreed to provide the soft gear which is the gear that will
be hanging from the hook of the crane.
Commissioner Miller asked what arrangements had been made
for training longshoremen to operate the crane. Director
Smith responded that the purchase agreement provided two
weeks of training supplied by the vendor - one week focused
on the technical aspects of the crane and the other week
focused on its operational aspects. He added that Local
4 would be asked to submit names of members to be involved
in the training sessions. Director Smith added that the
three stevedore companies operating at the Port have petitioned
PMA to include funds for training in the operation of the
new mobile harbor crane in its next budget cycle. He added
that staff would confirm that PMA funds are in place for
mobile harbor crane operation training prior to delivery
of the crane. Mr. Smith also said that the contract provided
for up to four people to travel to the factory so they could
watch the crane being put together and become familiar with
its internal workings.
On motion by Commissioner Baker, seconded by Commissioner
Wolfe, and carried unanimously, the Port of Vancouver USA
Board of Commissioners authorized the Executive Director
to sign a contract for a mobile harbor crane with Liebherr
Cranes, Inc. for a not to exceed amount of $3,276,650, subject
to acceptable contract modifications.
UNFINISHED BUSINESS
RTC High Capacity Corridor Transit Study
Dean Lookingbill, Regional Transportation Council (RTC)
Executive Director, explained that RTC received notification
from the Federal Transit Administration that a $1.488 million
grant for the High Capacity Corridor Transit Study to be
conducted throughout Clark County was being awarded and
required a $372,000 local match. He said that Clark County
provided $150,000 of that local match, leaving $222,000
to be raised from other local jurisdictions. Mr. Lookingbill
relayed that at the last RTC meeting the City of Vancouver
felt it should split the remaining difference with C-TRAN
and, as a result, was expected to provide $111,000 of that
balance. He added that the C-TRAN Board was considering
participating in the funding process and its next meeting's
agenda included a $55,000 commitment. He went on to say
that the C-TRAN Board might agree to an amount larger than
$55,000, but had expressed belief that smaller jurisdictions
within Clark County should also participate in the funding
of the local match.
The Commissioners discussed the matter with Mr. Lookingbill
and Executive Director Paulson and agreed that it would
be placed on the Port's May 23rd agenda for further consideration
since the C-TRAN Board would have made a final decision
on its level of financial contribution by that time.
Port Commission Salary
It was agreed that consideration of changing the salary
of the Port of Vancouver USA Board of Commissioners would
be deferred until the president of the Commission requests
that it be included on a future agenda for board consideration
no later than Spring 2007.
Port Contracts Log
Executive Director Paulson presented a Port of Vancouver
USA Personal Services Contract Log and a Public Works Contract
Log dated May 9, 2006, to the Commissioners for their information.
NEW BUSINESS
Request from Fort Vancouver Regional Library
re: LIFT Program
Executive Director Paulson explained that the Fort Vancouver
Regional Library had requested the Port of Vancouver USA's
support of its efforts to use incremental property tax and
sales tax funding, pursuant to the recently-passed LIFT
Bill, for construction of a new library building and underground
parking facility. He said that the new library facility
would be included in the proposed River West development
plan on the former Copps property in downtown Vancouver.
Mr. Paulson said the Library Board must have consent of
all local government agencies that would be forgoing an
increase in taxes as a result of its use of LIFT funding,
and had requested the Port's assistance in encouraging Clark
County to support its efforts. Mr. Paulson presented a draft
letter of support, relative to the Fort Vancouver Regional
Library/LIFT funding, addressed to the Clark County Board
of Commissioners and discussed the proposal with the Commissioners.
On motion by Commissioner Wolfe, seconded by Commissioner
Miller, and carried unanimously, the Port of Vancouver USA
Board of Commissioners authorized delivery of a letter to
the Clark County Board of Commissioners encouraging them
to participate in the Fort Vancouver Regional Library's
efforts to use incremental property tax and sales tax funding,
pursuant to the recently-passed LIFT Bill, for construction
of a new library building and parking facility.
CREDC Funding
Executive Director Paulson explained that he had placed
this item on the agenda because CREDC had been holding discussions,
primarily with local public agencies, about the possibility
of increasing public financial participation in that organization.
He said the Port should not lose sight of the private investment
and asked Commissioner Wolfe to address the issue since
he is the Port's representative on the CREDC Board.
Commissioner Wolfe said it was premature to hold an in-depth
conversation on the subject at this meeting because the
agency is now trying to determine whether or not the paradigm,
relative to CREDC that was created in the 1980s, remains
appropriate in today's economic development of Clark County.
He went on to say a CREDC committee was assessing the issue
including how, if at all, the funding mechanism might change,
as well as whether or not the compelling reason for actually
having economic development remains viable today. He said
that the City of Vancouver and Clark County had suggested
that they were willing to invest a lot more money into the
CREDC agency if fundamental changes in performance expectations
are agreed upon.
Commissioner Wolfe said this subject was being discussed
at this meeting strictly as a "heads up" and that
more information would follow as the committee proceeds
with its charge and ongoing discussions relative to the
level of financial participation continue.
ACCOUNTS PAYABLE
On motion by Commissioner Miller, seconded by Commissioner
Baker, and carried unanimously, the Port of Vancouver USA
Board of Commissioners ratified and approved payment of
April 2006 Vouchers 018195 - 018615 in the amount of $2,318,584.15
and April 2006 Payroll Checks 04206 - 04225 and Direct Deposits
15110 - 15219 in the amount of $197,080.97.
EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR
AND STAFF REPORTS
Executive Director Paulson reported that he gave a Port
presentation to the American Association of University Women
on April 25 and the Vancouver Executives Group
on April 27.
Communications Specialist Sue Groth reported on this year's
successful "Take Your Child to Work" event which
occurred April 27 at the Port. She said that 24 children
of Port staff participated in the day's activities which
included spending time with parents; a port tour complete
with equipment demonstrations at the maintenance shop, observation
of an auto ship unloading, and a stop at Pacific Coast Shredding;
a picnic lunch at Vancouver Lake Park; an Operation Lifesaver
train safety demonstration, courtesy of BNSF; a critter
count exploration of wetlands at Parcel 2; and an opportunity
to build their own trains out of Twinkies and candies.
Executive Director Paulson thanked Ms. Groth and all others
who helped make the event such a grand success.
Executive Director Paulson reported on the following other
Port-related events:
- Port Legislative Event, which was held on April 28.
He thanked the Commissioners for attending;
- City of Vancouver/Port of Vancouver Joint Workshop,
which was held May 1 at City Hall;
- Port visit by Representative Deb Wallace, along with
WPPA Executive Director Pat Jones and three legislative
staffers-two from the House and one from the Senate- on
May 3; and a
- Tour of the Port of Seattle by Mr. Paulson, Todd Coleman,
Addison Jacobs and Katy Brooks on May 4, which focused
on mutual rail issues. He added that a trip to the Port
of Tacoma was planned for May 22.
Community Relations Manager Katy Brooks reported on the
May 4th meeting of the Fruit Valley Neighborhood Association,
which Environmental Services Director Patty Boyden attended,
and said that Director Boyden attended to speak on two different
topics: TCE in-home air monitoring and results of the 26th
Ave./Port transportation study. She said that Craig Rankine,
from DOE, gave a status report that a group of South Fruit
Valley homes had been monitored and results were expected
shortly. She mentioned that this was part of ongoing efforts
to keep the neighborhood updated on the TCE clean up progress.
Ms. Brooks pointed out that both Cadet and the Port have
worked hard over the past years to make sure the clean up
process has been transparent and this meeting was part of
ongoing efforts to that end.
Ms. Brooks reported that Anne Sylvester, from Parametrix,
presented the traffic modeling/study results to the group
and fielded questions. She said that the information was
welcomed and plans are underway for keeping the neighborhood
informed as the NEPA continues.
Executive Director Paulson reminded the Commissioners of
the WPPA Spring Meeting, scheduled May 17 through 19 at
Semiahmoo Resort in Blaine, Washington.
COMMISSIONER REPORTS
Commissioner Wolfe mentioned that he had given his report
earlier in the meeting when he discussed CREDC funding issues.
He added that meetings that he had attended during the past
two weeks had already been discussed by others during this
meeting.
Commissioner Miller said that he had participated in a
tour of the State School for the Blind last week, and he
highly recommended that everyone do the same since the tour
was highly informative and well presented.
Commissioner Miller reported that he attended the Legislative
Event at the Port and the Mayor's Welcoming Luncheon at
the Discovery Walks on April 28; the joint Port and City
of Vancouver Workshop on May 1; an RTC meeting on May 2;
and, the Clark County Skills Center Foundation Dinner on
May 4.
Commissioner Baker reported that she attended the Port's
Legislative Event and the Mayor's Welcoming Luncheon at
the Discovery Walks on April 28, as well as the Discovery
Walks VIP Dinner on April 30; the joint City/Port Workshop
on May 1; the Symphony Tea for Women on May 2, where 2002
Miss America was present; and, the Clark County Skills Center
Foundation Dinner on May 4.
WORKSHOP
The Board of Commissioners and staff held a brief workshop
on the Port's proposed rail routes and associated property
acquisitions from 11 to 11:25 a.m..
ADJOURNMENT
There being no further business
to come before the Port of Vancouver USA Board of Commissioners,
the May 9, 2006, regular meeting was adjourned at 11:25
a.m. by Commission President Baker.